• Skip to main content
  • Skip to header right navigation
  • Skip to site footer

Kept Light Photography

Photography and Writing by A. Cemal Ekin

  • Home
  • Articles
    • All Articles
    • List of Topics
    • Foundations
    • Genre »
      • Abstract
      • Architecture
      • Infrared
      • Landscape
      • Monochrome
      • Nature
      • Still Life
      • Street Photography
      • Travel
    • Color Management
    • Computer
    • Ballet
    • Exhibits & Publications
    • Family Photographs
    • Gear
    • Lightroom
    • Photographers
    • Photography
    • Photoshop
    • Rhode Island
    • Neighborhood
    • WordPress
  • Portfolios
    • About Portfolios
    • Exhibits, Ballet, Publications
    • Selected Bodies of Work
    • All Portfolios
  • Purchase
  • Achievements
  • Workshops
    • Digital Printing Workflow
    • Private Mentoring Sessions
    • Speaking
  • About
    • Kept Light
    • Origins
    • A. Cemal Ekin
    • Subscribe to Updates
    • Privacy Policy
    • Contact

Home » Yet Another Photoshop Sharpening Method: Edge Mask

Yet Another Photoshop Sharpening Method: Edge Mask

September 3, 2013 by A. Cemal Ekin
No sharpening appliedModerate sharpening no edge mask

After the series of posts related to sharpening in Photoshop, one reader commented and asked whether split sharpening or edge-mask sharpening would be a better approach. I indicated in my reply that edge-mask is just that, a mask created from the edge information in the image applied to a sharpened layer and that there was no reason one could not combine both. This brief post will present a new action, essentially a modified Smart Object Split Sharpening which creates an edge mask before the sharpening and applies that mask to the smart filters.

Edge Mask Sharpening in Photoshop

When will an edge mask be really useful? If the image has large low-frequency areas, like a portrait of a child or a woman, or some landscape with a large sky area with clouds, an edge mask may help protect those low-frequency areas from the effects of sharpening. In this post, you will see some sample sharpened images that are often pushed over the sensible levels to show the effect of an edge mask. When the sharpening parameters are applied with restraint the importance of the edge mask diminishes. I will note the images as carefully as I can so that you can see the comparative evaluation of various before-after images.

Download the Sharpening Action

Before going any further you may want to download the new Ekin Sharpen action set which will include all the previous ones and one new one, Split USM SO With Edge Mask. For instructions on where to copy it, refer to the previous post on sharpening.

When you are ready to apply sharpening to your image, open the Actions panel, highlight Sharpen:  Split USM SO With Edge Mask, click on the play button at the bottom of the panel, and wait for it to run its course. In the end, you will have a smart object with two Unsharp Mask filters applied, the lower is for lightened edges and the upper is the darkened edges. You can double-click on each and adjust the parameters from their default levels of Amount=10, Radius=1, Threshold=0 to suit the needs of your image.

Let us take a look at some pairs of images. You can move the slider bar right and left to see the before or after states of each pair. What these states represent are indicated above each image. You should note the following:

  1. The image is a 100% crop from a digital capture
  2. The parts that need sharpening are the eye and eyelashes, the eyebrow, and the hair
  3. The part that should be protected is the skin
  4. When a reasonable amount of sharpening applied the difference between edge-masked or with no mask is negligible
  5. When aggressive sharpening is needed (which is not in this case but presented to show the results) edge masking has a beneficial effect
  6. I applied the same parameters to the lighten and darken components in the smart filter to make comparisons easier

Without the Edge Mask

To start with, let me present a pair of images sharpened with the same parameters, A=300, R=1 T=0. The Before-image is without the edge mask, and the After-image is with the edge mask applied. Keep in mind that even with the edge mask applied, this is probably too much sharpening. That said, the sharpening on the eyelashes remains essentially the same with or without the edge mask while the skin sharpening is suppressed with the edge mask applied (after state).

Before Edge Mask AppliedAfter Edge Mask Applied

With the Edge Mask

Now let us take a look at another pair where A=200, R=0.5, T=0. Again, the before state represents without, and the after state represents with the edge mask applied. You will note that the skin is not overly sharpened even without the edge mask applied. However, if the skin area showed some noise, sharpening would make it more visible and the edge mask would be quite beneficial.

Before Edge MaskAfter Edge Mask

The final pair will show the image with no sharpening applied and a reasonable level of sharpening applied without the edge mask, and with the parameters, A=200, R=0.5, T=0. Even though the radius is kept small to make sharpening focus on fine detail like the eyelashes, the effect on the skin is minimal.

No sharpening appliedModerate sharpening no edge mask

So, you be the judge whether you would like to add an edge mask to your sharpening or not.

Related

Category: PhotoshopTag: Photography, Photoshop

Kept Light Photography

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Don Park

    September 3, 2013 at 5:54 pm

    Thanks for updating on Split Sharpening. I now understand when the edge mask is beneficial. I personally prefer using the edge mask version all the time.

    One more point: What do you think if I add “Blend If” to the Split USM with Edge Mask layer in order to restrict the sharpening effect only to a specified tonal width with smooth transition, e.g. move Black slider from 0 to 15/45 and White slider from 255 to 205/235 on “This Layer”. I am not sure if this idea may be a double insurance to the White Halos just in case I am careless about the over-sharpening for any reasons and I don’t have to use black colored brush to paint on the edges to control White Halos.

    Don

    • A. Cemal Ekin

      September 3, 2013 at 9:22 pm

      Blend if is always an option. However, in this split sharpening with smart objects you need to apply that to the smart object. Although you can change the opacity and the blend mode of each USM smart filter, there is no separate blend if for each smart filter. Changing the blend if sliders of the smart object should allow further control. It is also important to realize that when sharpening is applied with restraint and finesse it needs less interference as the last image set shows.

      Cemal

New Post Updates

Consider subscribing to new post updates. You can unsubscribe instantly anytime you want. You will only receive a short e-mail when a new post is published.

Visit Subscribe Page

Privacy Policy

The Privacy Policy mainly addresses the concerns that may be related to the platform and its technology. We do not collect or share any information about the visitors.

Copyright Information

All photographs and writing are:
Copyright © 2022 A. Cemal Ekin · Kept Light Photography. All rights reserved. No work may be used for any purpose without prior written permission.

Contact me for more information.

Copyright © 2022 · A. Cemal Ekin · All Rights Reserved